You’ve been referred to an endodontist—but wait, do endodontists pull teeth? Or is their role something entirely different? If you’re unsure whether to expect a root canal or an extraction, you’re not alone. In this article, we’ll clear up the confusion about what endodontists really do—and when, if ever, they actually remove teeth. The answer might surprise you.
Learn more about treatments with endodontist in Queens, NY
TL;DR
Endodontists are dental specialists trained to save natural teeth, not extract them. They diagnose complex pain, perform root canals, and use advanced imaging to treat internal tooth issues. Extractions are only recommended when a tooth is beyond repair—due to decay, gum disease, failed treatment, or crowding. Choosing between root canal and extraction depends on restorability, function, cost, and long-term outcomes.
What is the Difference Between Endodontist and Tooth Extraction?
Endodontists and tooth extraction serve very different roles in dental care. Endodontists are specialists who focus on saving teeth—not removing them. After completing two to three years of advanced training beyond dental school, endodontists become experts in diagnosing and treating issues related to the dental pulp and root canals. Their primary goal is to preserve natural teeth whenever possible.
Often referred to as “root canal specialists,” endodontists treat complex pain, perform root canal therapy, and utilize advanced tools like operating microscopes and CBCT imaging to manage challenging cases within the tooth. Extraction, on the other hand, involves the removal of a tooth and is generally considered a last resort—only recommended when the pieces cannot be saved.
Know What Endodontists Do
Endodontists are dental specialists who focus on saving teeth by treating issues inside it—especially when general dentists need additional expertise. Their work involves advanced diagnostics, precision procedures, and specialized tools to manage complex cases.
- Diagnose complex tooth and facial pain
They assess difficult-to-trace pain, especially when the source isn’t obvious to general dentists. - Perform root canal therapy
This includes removing infected pulp, cleaning and disinfecting the canals, then sealing the root to preserve the natural piece. - Use advanced imaging tools
Endodontists use dental operating microscopes and CBCT scans to visualize intricate root structures with high precision. - Handle endodontic surgery
When standard root canal treatments fail, they perform surgical procedures like apicoectomy or retreatment to save the teeth.
Learn When Extraction is Needed
Extraction becomes necessary when a tooth cannot be saved or poses a risk to oral health. Dentists typically explore restorative options first, but in certain cases, removal is the most appropriate course.
5 Common Reasons for Extraction:
- Severe decay or damage
When too much of the structure is lost, making restoration impossible. - Advanced periodontal disease
Gum disease that causes significant bone loss or loose teeth may require extraction. - Impacted wisdom teeth
These can lead to pain, infection, or pericoronitis and are often removed as a preventive measure. - Unsuccessful root canal treatment
If retreatment or surgery isn’t a viable solution, extraction may be the only option. - Orthodontic needs
In cases of overcrowding, a healthy tooth may be extracted to help align the bite and create necessary space.
Root Canal vs. Extraction
When dealing with a severely damaged or infected tooth, two primary treatment options are typically considered: root canal therapy or extraction. Each has its own goals, procedures, benefits, and drawbacks, depending on the condition of it and the patient’s overall oral health needs.
| Aspect | Root Canal (Endodontic Therapy) | Extraction |
| Goal | Eliminate infection and preserve the natural tooth | Remove the problematic tooth entirely |
| Procedure | Remove infected pulp, clean, shape, and seal canals; restore with a crown | Remove tooth from socket; can be simple or surgical |
| Advantages | – Maintains natural teeth- Preserves jawbone and alignment- Often lower long-term cost | – Quick solution- Initially less expensive |
| Disadvantages | – May require multiple visits- Risk of re-infection- Needs crown or restoration | – Requires tooth replacement- Risk of bone loss & shifting- Higher long-term cost |
When Endodontists Refer for Extraction
While endodontists are specialists trained to preserve natural teeth, there are cases where extraction becomes the most appropriate recommendation. When saving a tooth is no longer feasible, referral for removal is based on sound clinical judgment.
- Severe structural loss or fractures that render the tooth non-restorable.
- Advanced periodontal disease or root resorption that compromises the tooth’s support.
- Traumatic injuries or root fractures that negatively affect the long-term prognosis.
- Irreparable surrounding tissue damage or failure of previous endodontic treatments where no additional interventions would be effective.
In such cases, the goal shifts from preservation to preventing further complications and planning appropriate replacement options in collaboration with other dental specialists.
Making the Right Choice
Deciding between root canal therapy and extraction involves evaluating whether the piece can be saved and restored effectively. A main factor is the tooth’s restorability—meaning whether enough healthy structure remains to support a crown or other restoration. Teeth that are structurally sound and functionally important—such as those involved in chewing or visible in the smile—are often strong candidates for preservation through root canal treatment.
Beyond structural considerations, long-term outcomes and costs play a role. While a root canal may involve higher upfront costs and multiple appointments, it can prevent the need for more extensive future treatments like bridges or implants. In contrast, extraction might appear more affordable initially, but the loss of a tooth can lead to shifting, bone loss, and the need for replacement—often resulting in greater expenses over time.
Key Takeaways:
- Endodontists specialize in saving teeth, not removing them.
They complete advanced training in diagnosing and treating dental pulp and root canal issues using high-precision tools and techniques. - Extraction is not typically performed by endodontists.
Extractions are a last resort, used when a tooth is too damaged, infected, or unstable to be restored. - What endodontists do includes:
- Diagnosing hard-to-trace tooth and facial pain.
- Performing root canals to remove infected pulp and save the tooth.
- Using advanced imaging (microscopes, CBCT) to handle complex cases.
- Conducting endodontic surgeries when needed (e.g., apicoectomy).
- Common reasons for extraction include:
- Extensive decay or damage.
- Advanced gum disease and bone loss.
- Impacted wisdom teeth with complications.
- Failed root canal therapy with no viable retreatment.
- Orthodontic needs (e.g., creating space for alignment).
- Root canal vs. extraction:
- Root canal preserves the tooth, helps maintain bone and bite, but may require more visits and a crown.
- Extraction offers quick relief, but often leads to higher long-term costs due to tooth replacement needs and bone loss.
- When endodontists refer for extraction:
- Cases with non-restorable tooth structure, advanced periodontal disease, traumatic injuries, or failed treatments without alternatives.
- Making the right treatment choice depends on:
- Whether the tooth is restorable and functional.
- Long-term implications for bite, bone, and cost.
- Patient health, preference, and tolerance for procedures.
- Preserving natural teeth generally offers better outcomes when feasible.
Sources.
Dablanca-Blanco, A. B., Castelo-Baz, P., Miguéns-Vila, R., Alvarez-Novoa, P., & Martín-Biedma, B. (2022). Endodontic rotary files, what should an endodontist know?. Medicina, 58(6), 719. https://doi.org/10.3390/medicina58060719
Shareef, R. A., Chaturvedi, S., Suleman, G., Elmahdi, A. E., & Elagib, M. F. A. (2020). Analysis of tooth extraction causes and patterns. Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences, 8(D), 36-41. https://doi.org/10.3889/oamjms.2020.3784